default avatar
Welcome to the site! Login or Signup below.
Not you?||
Logout|My Dashboard

Don’t deny feelings for animals

Font Size:
Default font size
Larger font size

Posted: Thursday, July 12, 2012 2:48 pm

In reference to the 4-H articles (June 20), Sheila Gill’s response (June 27), and the subsequent responses: I am a confused meat eater. I like the taste of meat. My body seems to crave it when I have been a vegetarian, so I try to eat meat that is grass-fed, organic, and sustainably and lovingly raised. Though I have chickens, cats and dogs, I could personally never eat them because I have grown to love them, and I believe they love me.

When my kids were little and we went to the 4-H fairs, they wanted to buy cows, pigs, and bulls to “save them” from being eaten. They were having the same confusion I was having, reconciling the love and care of animals, then the eating of them!

There are numerous studies published on the feelings of animals, so to say, in essence, as Bill Gass and Heather McAvoy (July 4) have that the 4-H animals are not raised as pets, I think we are trying to deny that we have feelings for animals or that they have them for us. This is not anthropomorphizing, it is just denial and possibly a touch of brainwashing of the children. I doubt there is one of those kids who did not have fondness, i.e. “love,” for the animals they so carefully tended before sale.

Being a meat eater in our culture requires a certain amount of denial, especially when we see the hideous and inhumane ways animals are treated and raised for food, as pets, and for human “pleasure,” such as rodeos, bullfights, cockfights, dogfights, etc.

Why deny what plainly exists? We love animals, they love us, and sometimes we eat them. I just hope we all could love them and respect them in the way the 4-H children apparently do, with full acceptance of our feelings, including guilt.

Chris Pritchard

Moss Beach

Welcome to the discussion.

1 comment:

  • Heather McAvoy posted at 9:28 am on Fri, Jul 13, 2012.

    Heather McAvoy Posts: 16

    Hi Chris: To clear up an error: I did not say that 4-H animals are not pets so I think you're confusing my comments with someone else's comments. In fact, many 4-H animals are pets. I think you misunderstood my point about anthropomorphization, which is "the attribution of human characteristics to nonhuman beings and objects" Anyone who experiences empathy has feelings for animals, to be sure. The 4-H youth who raise animals, whether they are to provide meat, eggs, dairy products or companionship (or a combination thereof), care enormously for their animals. My point was that in order to provide excellent and humane care for animals, these kids learn the unique needs of each species. Those needs are often not the same as human needs. To see them care for their animals it is clear, they do so with full acceptance of their own very human feelings for their animals.


Popular/Commented Stories

This Week's Editorial Cartoon


10:11 am | See more

More Editorial Cartoons

Connect with us