Opinion : Nothing new about churches participating in political dialogue : Half Moon Bay Review, California
Home News Opinion Sports Talkabout Obituaries Community Classifieds Calendar Archives About Us Ad Rates

Nothing new about churches participating in political dialogue


Published/Last Modified on Wednesday, Nov 12, 2008 - 02:42:48 pm PST

The paths of church and state are rarely parallel. They intersect for a variety of reasons, some more compelling than others. Sometimes the line that Americans would like to think separates the secular from the religious disappears because men and women of conscience simply must speak their mind about events of the day. They owe it to their faith. And they owe it to their country.

That is the way it was for the Rev. James Reeb.

On the front page of today’s newspaper is the story of a common American family of uncommon moral standing. Long before Anne and Karen Reeb settled on the Coastside, their father, James, died for our nation’s sins. He was killed in Selma, Ala., after a march called to shed light on the racial inequalities that prevented black Americans from achieving full citizenship.

Reeb was a Unitarian minister and before that was ordained in the Presbyterian Church. For him, there was right and there was wrong, and the fact that he was a member of the clergy had no bearing on his choice to speak his mind.

Over the last election cycle, a similar calling guided some religious people to speak out in favor of Proposition 8, the successful ballot measure that banned gay marriage in California. And last week a minor tumult erupted on the Review’s online forum because Our Lady of the Pillar Catholic Church in Half Moon Bay reportedly allowed “Yes on 8” signs on church grounds. Opponents of the proposition claimed the church violated rules governing its tax-exempt status by taking a stand on the measure.

As a practical matter, it appears there is an important distinction in the tax code governing church exemptions. They may support legislation like Prop. 8 and retain their tax-exempt status. They may not support candidates, political parties or political action committees, which could simply become tools of the church.

But you have to wonder whether the same Prop. 8 opponents who complain about the Half Moon Bay church’s political activity would have also railed against Martin Luther King Jr. for his support of the Voting Rights Act of 1965. That’s not to say the two campaigns were analogous; they were not. King fought for equality, the Catholic Church, in this instance, favored discrimination. But you can’t very well applaud the outspoken King and Reeb on the one hand and slap leaders at Our Lady of the Pillar with the other.

— Clay Lambert

Want to talk about this story? Start a topic on Talkabout.

Multimedia



Living Green


Photo Galleries

Classifieds

Contact Us


Staff Directory

Community

New grants assure help for dozens of child abuse victims


Family Service Agency of San Mateo County, a nonprofit dedicated to helping struggling children, families and older adults improve their lives, announced Tuesday that it has received additional funding to fight the effects of child abuse.

More community news

Reader Poll

Calendar

Upcoming Events:

Weather